Some Reflections on the Assisted Dying Bill

Last week, on Black Friday of all days, the UK Parliament voted to advance Kim Leadbeater MP’s hastily presented Assisted Dying Bill.

I appreciate that for so many who are championing this bill, their motives are deeply personal. They’ve watched loved ones suffer or have lived with serious pain themselves. To them, helping someone end their life, if it is their wish, seems the most loving thing to do.

Personally, having watched my father-in-law suffer with vascular dementia these last years, I have seen first-hand what it is like when an illness affects pretty much every second of someone’s day. Rod has held on for years longer than the doctors predicted. But it has been slow and painful, and I can empathise with those who support this bill because they don’t want their loved ones to endure unnecessary suffering.

But as compassionate as these sentiments may appear on one level, this bill – which fundamentally seeks to legalise assisted suicide – could change how we as a society see illness and disability, and death itself. To me, compassion means caring for those in their final moments and affirming their worth, no matter how frail they may seem.

A Slippery Slope

I believe this bill is dangerous. History shows how safeguards and assurances initially promised in this kind of legislation can erode over time. When the Abortion Act was introduced in 1967, it was meant as a measure for extreme cases, yet today it has expanded far beyond its original intent, essentially resulting in abortion on demand – despite the commitments of politicians and campaigners at the time.

The Assisted Dying Bill could go the same way. In places like Belgium, the Netherlands, Canada, and Oregon, where assisted dying or euthanasia is now legal, laws that started out tightly controlled and narrowly applied have widened considerably within a relatively short time.

Another big problem is that legalising assisted suicide could subtly encourage the vulnerable – especially the elderly, the disabled, and the terminally ill – to view their lives as a burden. When society begins to see assisted suicide as a legitimate option on the table, those who feel their lives are a strain on others may feel under pressure to see it as the ‘right’ thing to do, even if they want to live. For many facing illness or disability, the wish to ease the pressure on their families, financial or otherwise, could become a kind of coercion.

This is how a ‘right to die’ could quickly become a perceived ‘duty to die’. Safeguards will never be able to fully protect against coercion or abuse, nor can they guarantee that such decisions to choose death over life will be made free of outside pressure.

Not Over Yet

Despite such concerns, 330 MPs voted in favour of the bill last Friday, with 275 MPs opposing it. However, the Assisted Dying Bill is not yet law. Its passage to royal assent depends on another reading and further approval in the House of Commons, followed by scrutiny in the House of Lords. So there is still time. We need to keep making our case, especially about how weak the safeguards are in practice and where this could lead.

If you live in the UK, consider writing (again) to your MP to express your concerns and disappointment, or to thank them if they opposed the bill (see how they voted here). It helps to mention the examples from other countries and the need to protect the vulnerable. Let’s pray that more MPs will reconsider and vote against the bill at the third reading.

And despite euphemisms such as ‘dignity in dying’ and ‘assisted dying’, this is ‘assisted suicide’ – the deliberate act of ending a life prematurely by providing lethal medication. It is not about letting a disease take its natural course or opting against further medical treatment.

What the Debate Exposed

Much of the debate about the Assisted Dying Bill has exposed the lack of proper resources and training for end-of-life care. Many people fear suffering because they don’t receive the support they need. That money would be far better spent on palliative care and hospices, which remain badly underfunded.

Good palliative care can ease suffering. It helps people face death with their pain managed and their dignity intact. That’s why it’s so concerning that we are moving towards assisted dying on the NHS while failing to prioritise good care for the dying.

I’ve seen this time and again in more than 25 years of pastoral ministry, watching people with terminal illnesses find real joy even while they were suffering. Facing death with faith and honesty can bring peace and a wonderful sense of release. As Paul puts it, for the Christian “to die is gain” (Philippians 1:21), and that holds true however death comes. Even in the shadow of death, we can experience God’s presence and peace, knowing heaven is ahead of us.

From Black Friday to Good Friday

The vote on Black Friday reminds me of another Friday – Good Friday – when Jesus chose to lay His life down on the cross. His sacrifice shows how much every human life is worth to God, including lives marked by suffering. That gives us every reason to work at relieving suffering without ending lives, and to make sure the vulnerable know they are valued.

Proverbs 24:11-12 commands us, “Rescue those being led away to death; hold back those staggering toward slaughter. If you say, ‘But we knew nothing about this,’ does not he who weighs the heart perceive it? Does not he who guards your life know it? Will he not repay everyone according to what they have done?” This is the time to answer that call.

Link copied to clipboard!
Previous
Previous

Faith, Football, and the Fine Line of Inclusivity

Next
Next

The Thanksgiving Telescope