Humanism on Borrowed Capital

Andrew Copson’s short letter ‘There Is No Revival of Christianity in Britain’ in The Guardian would have been a familiar piece of secular confidence on any ordinary day. Published on Easter Sunday, however – the day Christians mark the resurrection of Jesus Christ – it landed differently. That is why I’ve decided to respond: not only because Copson’s argument rests on assumptions that deserve scrutiny, but because humanism is once again spending moral capital it did not mint.

The Moral Vision Humanism Didn’t Create

Copson’s central claim is that younger generations are turning away from religion and grounding their lives instead in “the humanist values of reason, kindness and personal responsibility”. Few would quarrel with those values. The trouble starts when you ask where they came from.

Humanism likes to present itself as morally self-sufficient, as though it simply discovered kindness by looking hard enough at the world. But historically, that is not what happened. The moral architecture humanists often appeal to – things like universal human dignity and the duty to care for the weak – was not generated by secular reason operating in a vacuum. It is actually the inheritance of a Christian civilisation.

The idea that every human being has equal and inviolable worth is not self-evident. It is, in fact, a profoundly specific claim, rooted in the Christian conviction that human beings are made in the image of God. Remove that foundation and the language of dignity and rights is left hanging – still spoken, but much harder to justify.

This matters because Copson’s argument leans, more than he lets on, on the very tradition he’s trying to sideline. He wants the fruits of Christianity – its moral clarity, its concern for the vulnerable – without acknowledging the roots that sustain them. That isn’t intellectual neutrality; it’s historical amnesia.

What the Public Square Is Built On

On the public square, Copson argues that non-religious people should be recognised as a community with a positive ethical worldview and given equal standing. In one sense, this is uncontroversial – and Christians should have no interest in excluding others from public life.

But what Copson doesn’t stop to consider is the public square itself. The kind of society Copson seems to be appealing to – a liberal democracy in which people of fundamentally different convictions can live side by side and say what they believe without fear – is not a historical inevitability. It rests on specific moral commitments: that individuals possess inherent dignity, that conscience should not be coerced, that power must be limited, and that even those we disagree with deserve equal standing under the law.

Those commitments have a history. They came out of a long moral and intellectual tradition in which Christian ideas about the conscience and the limits of authority played a decisive role. The belief that each individual has equal and intrinsic worth, for example, is far more naturally grounded in the Christian conviction that human beings are made in the image of God than in a purely material account of reality.

I’m not claiming Christianity owns liberal democracy, or that non-Christians can’t sincerely support it – plenty do. My point is narrower. The freedoms Copson rightly values don’t explain themselves, and the moral assumptions beneath them were formed, and are still largely sustained, by the Christian vision of the human person.

This is my recurring frustration with the humanist project. It insists on equal standing in a public square it didn’t build, while offering no clear account of why its central commitments to dignity and equal rights should remain binding if detached from the worldview that gave them coherence in the first place.

So yes, humanists should have a voice in public life. But a more honest conversation would acknowledge that the conditions which make that possible are neither neutral nor inevitable – and that Christianity remains far more integral to them than most humanists admit.

The Real Religious Landscape

Then there is the question of decline and “revival”. Copson is within his rights to criticise the “Quiet Revival” report (and I have written about YouGov’s error here, while still affirming the general trends that the Bible Society’s original commentary identified). Unreliable data should be challenged. But Copson proceeds to make a similar mistake in reverse – treating a particular dataset as if it settles the entire question.

His reliance on Church of England figures is especially revealing. Although I know many Anglican churches that are thriving, it is the case that the Church of England as a whole is presently shrinking. But, regardless, this is not synonymous with the whole story of Christianity in the UK, and treating it as such is to misunderstand the landscape entirely.

There is growth elsewhere. Pentecostal and other evangelical churches are seeing it, and so are many Roman Catholic parishes and Orthodox communities – churches across traditions are reporting new faces and renewed interest. These are not marginal footnotes; they are a significant part of the story. By dismissing them, Copson ends up doing precisely what he criticises – drawing sweeping conclusions from selective evidence.

Beyond statistics, there are cultural signals that cannot be dismissed. Reports of Gen Z exploring faith are becoming increasingly common – and I’m seeing this firsthand. Across politics, too, there’s been a noticeable willingness to speak positively about Christianity; a quick look at party social media over Easter makes that clear. And the same pattern shows up in places that once felt firmly secular: athletes talking openly about prayer, and broadcasters who now treat faith as an ordinary part of public life rather than a curiosity.

I wouldn’t call any of this a full-scale revival. But it does suggest the story of inevitable decline is starting to look dated.

The Story Secularism Wants

What Copson’s letter ultimately rests on is a familiar narrative: religion fades and the future is secular. It is a story that has been told for decades – and yet reality stubbornly refuses to conform.

The UK is becoming less religious in some ways and more religiously complicated in others. Old institutions are weakening, certainly. Yet faith keeps turning up where the secularisation thesis says it shouldn’t, often among people with no church background and with a confidence nobody predicted. Even the growing number who describe themselves as non‑religious are not, for the most part, committed humanists. Many are simply drifting. And drift, for all its sociological interest, is not a worldview.

Any fair account has to admit two things: that secularisation is real, and that it is not the whole story. If humanism wants to be taken seriously as a moral vision, it must do more than assert its values. It must explain them – and explain why, in a purely secular universe, they should bind any of us at all. I’d genuinely like to hear Copson’s answer.

@dominicdesouzauk

Happy Easter, friends! ✝️✨ #HeIsRisen May this little recent sermon clip encourage Christian believers today… and perhaps stir the hearts of those still searching. “History points to Him. Reason leads to Him. The human heart longs for Him. And His power is still transforming lives today.” #JesusIsAlive #Easter

♬ original sound - Revd Dominic De Souza
Link copied to clipboard!
Previous
Previous

Christ Before Nation – A Call to Faithfulness in a Fractured Age

Next
Next

The Quiet Revival Report Withdrawn – Keep Calm & Carry On